Problem:
Confirming cmdwin with a UTF-8 character containing 0x80 does not complete the
command.
Solution:
Escape K_SPECIAL bytes while feeding the cmdwin input after confirmation.
- Replace newlines in the current cmdline with NULs when opening cmdwin,
and do the reverse when putting a cmdwin line back into the cmdline.
- Escape control characters with Ctrl-V when feeding cmdline.
Problem:
- If cmdwin window is split, ENTER in one does not close the others.
- If cmdwin is put into a different tabpage via <c-w>T, it stops working
(ENTER does not execute the cmd).
Solution:
- Close the buffer instead of the window.
- In the WinClosed handler, skip `M._cleanup()` unless this is the last
cmdwin window.
Problem:
Legacy cmdwin set 'buflisted', but new one doesn't.
https://github.com/neovim/neovim/issues/40431#issuecomment-4811593353
'buflisted' useful for:
- "bufferline" style tablines, they usually show only listed buffers.
- some automatic actions can be conditioned on whether a buffer is
listed; 'buflisted' signals that the buffer is "important enough".
Solution:
Set 'buflisted'.
Problem:
After ctrl-f from the cmdline, the last 2 lines of cmdwin are redundant.
Solution:
In `open_cmdwin`, clear the live cmdline so that unwinding it (via
Ctrl_C) does not add it to history.
Problem:
cmdwin (the `:q` cmdline buffer) has various limitations which require
special-casing all over the codebase.
Besides complicating the code, it also breaks async plugins if they try
to create buffers/windows after some work is done, if the user happens
to open cmdwin at the wrong the moment:
Lua callback: …/guh.nvim/lua/guh/util.lua:531:
E11: Invalid in command-line window; <CR> executes, CTRL-C quits
stack traceback:
[C]: in function 'nvim_buf_delete'
…/guh.nvim/lua/guh/util.lua:531: in function <…/guh.nvim/lua/guh/util.lua:526>
Solution:
Just say no to "inception". Reimplement cmdwin as a normal buffer+window.
All of the cmdwin contortions (in both core, and innocent plugins) exist
literally only to support "inception": recursive
cmdwin-in-cmdline-things, like `<c-r>=`, `/`, search-during-substitute,
`:input()`, etc. So we just won't support that (though I have
a potential plan for that later, which I call "modal parking lot").
The benefit is that plugins, and core, no longer have to care about
cmdwin.
BONUS:
- mouse-drag on vertical separators works (it only worked for
horizontal/statusline before)
- inccommand-in-cmdwin now works correctly, for free (thus don't need
#40077).
POTENTIAL FOLLOWUPS
- Drop `CHECK_CMDWIN` ("E11: Invalid in command-line window"), allow chaos.
- Unify `BUFLOCK_OK` / `LOCK_OK` ?
DESIGN:
- Eliminate lots of C globals, `EX_CMDWIN`, etc.
- `text_locked()` no longer reports true for cmdwin.
- cmdwin = a normal window with 'winfixbuf', 'bufhidden=wipe',
'buftype=nofile'. Invariants come from those options rather than
special cases throughout the codebase.
- `nv_record` for q:/q//q? calls Lua
`nlua_call_vimfn("vim._core.cmdwin", …)`. No `K_CMDWIN`
/ cmdline-reader detour.
- `cedit_key` (`c_CTRL-F`) schedules a deferred event that calls
`vim._core.cmdwin.open(type, content, pos)` and returns `Ctrl_C` so
the in-flight cmdline cancels. Reader state is not serialized; instead
the captured `(type, line, col)` is replayed via
`nvim_feedkeys(type..line.."<CR>", "nt", …)` after user confirms.
- On confirm/cancel: `<CR>` / `<C-C>` calls into Lua which closes the
window and re-feeds the cmdline.
BREAKING CHANGES:
- Expression-register cmdline (`<C-R>=` from insert-mode) no longer
supports cmdwin. Same applies to `input()` / `inputlist()` (already
covered by `text_locked`).
- Usage of cmdwin in macros/mappings will probably break (assuming they
ever worked).
Lewis Russell